Thursday, June 5, 2008

Answer to someone who claims God does not exist

reply to post by Conspiracy Realist
Sorry you have such a distorted view of what belief in God is all about. The way you describe it, it makes no sense. I do not think God created the universe knowing it would be defective. God created something perfect. He would have known that there was a potential for something to go wrong. We were not there and we do not know what the circumstances were that caused the fall of man. I think it is a bad idea to try to form a concept of what God is, by making up rules that he has to abide by, in order to be God. God does not take on a certain role, in order to suite our notions. We have no idea what it might mean, to know everything, so why do we automatically apply our deficient knowledge of that concept, onto God. What is God, to you? A universal spy? God went to the garden to talk with Adam, and Adam hid from him. God had to assume that there was something wrong. He had to ask Adam if he had eaten of the forbidden fruit.



posted on 5-6-2008 @ 03:35 AM
reply to post by Conspiracy Realist
Thanks for going to the trouble to explain what your opinion is on this matter. Sorry if your argument is not convincing, to me. We do not know exactly what was involved in the garden. We do not even know what it was, in the garden, that convinced Eve that it was OK to go ahead and eat of the tree. It is translated as serpent, but that is a guess. It is some sort of being and we assume that God created it. Eve uses that as an argument to justify her actions. If god created some sort of being that shows up and tells her something wrong, well it must be God's fault that she chose to believe it. You are using her logic. If Adam fell, because he bought into the deception, well, it must be God's fault because He put that possibility before him. Why would God do such a thing? You seem to know the answer. The answer you must, unavoidably come to, if we understand God, correctly. So, the solution, in your way of dealing with it, is to decide that there must not really be a God, because, why would we want to believe in something so hideous. Believing in God is Hideous because He created a world that we have no choice but to have to suffer and die. First off, I do not think the Bible tells us that. You may think it does. Maybe someone told you it does, and you believe it to be so. We might find ourselves in a predicament like that, but it does not mean our ancient ancestors had it that way. That is the whole reason for having this nice story, about the garden. It is to show us that at one time, everything was perfect and we had a nice life and we had the freedom of choice to be good or bad. It ruins the whole thing, if you inject the idea that it was nothing but a trap. That God created such weak humans that, given any temptation, we would be helpless to fall for it. I do not think God did that. I think God created extremely intelligent and good charactered people to inhabit His creation. But, the fact remains, that they did fall. That is the point, to tell us how we came to be such retched creatures. Of course, it has no value to you, if you turn it into a demonstration of the evilness of God. We do not live where Adam and Eve lived. We do not have the choices they had. The choice they made was effective for all their descendents. So, we can not choose to not be evil. We are born into it. But, we were born, and have a life, thanks to having our original parents, faulty as they are. We live for the sake of them. We are not here for some trial purpose. That was their option, not ours. But, they live on, through us, despite making the wrong choice.